Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-115.132.22.151-20160130112354/@comment-4911196-20160130142823

Sofy to Tigre began to show her direct affection at Epilogue of Volume 5 which later increased her scale to Volume 7 Chapter 3 (A ruler's Cruelty)

Lim start showing her indirect affection starting from Volume 3 Chapter 1 (Black Knight)

Valentina still play role of deceit like Roland which become semi-villain in this series. I haven't yet determine Fine's status throughout the story. You better read it anyway :D